PitchLens

What Homebrew looks for in a pitch deck

Homebrew is a seed-stage firm founded by Hunter Walk and Satya Patel that backs mission-driven founders solving large, urgent and valuable problems. They invest in 'people, not themes' — over-indexing on founder-market fit and the 'why' behind the company — and want businesses that 'feel like they are going to happen one way or another,' not ones that only exist if Homebrew blesses them. Since 2022 they moved away from raising traditional LP funds to investing their own evergreen capital, scaling back to mostly $100k-$500k checks with no ownership target and no LP pressure to flip companies early.

Stage focus: pre-seed, seed · Sectors: fintech, saas, developer platforms, ai ml, healthcare, robotics autonomy, commerce, hardware

What Homebrew wants on each slide

Problem

A large, urgent and valuable problem that the founder has firsthand experience with and cares deeply enough about to spend the next decade solving. The 'why' behind the problem matters as much as the problem itself.

“Does this founder or founding team have firsthand experience with the pain that they're addressing?” — Think Seed Like Homebrew (Mercury)
“You are solving a large, urgent and valuable problem” — Homebrew (home page)
“Do they have some story behind the why? For some it's vocational, for some it's academic, generational, demographic, or cultural.” — Hunter Walk

Solution

A credible product vision and direction — but they expect it to evolve. They want alignment on direction at investment while being comfortable with the product changing afterward.

“We want to have alignment around the product direction but we're comfortable with that changing after we make an investment.” — Think Seed Like Homebrew (Mercury)
“When we make an investment at the seed stage, we're trying to check the founding team, the market opportunity, and the product vision.” — Satya Patel
“Capital then becomes something that's going to help you take advantage of an insight you have or a hypothesis you're working on.” — Hunter Walk
“You are using technology to create substantive change, unleash new markets” — Homebrew (home page)

Market size

Not a giant TAM number — they care about addressability, where the first 1,000 customers come from, and whether the market is growing and the problem urgent. A crude TAM slide is treated skeptically.

“For me, at seed stage, there are so many more important questions about a market's attractiveness than its current overestimated size.” — Your Total Addressable Market Stat Is Probably a Lie
“On top of that it's actually not the total size that gets me most excited, it's the Addressability.” — Hunter Walk
“And if you think of all the people who currently have a pet, that's $80 GAZILLION DOLLARS of TAM” — Hunter Walk
“Yes there are lots of retail stores which could benefit from your commerce and loyalty program solution but where do the first 1,000 customers come from?” — Hunter Walk
“When you're pitching investors focus on the A in TAM. It'll help make your strategy more tangible, expose the depth of thought you have” — Hunter Walk

Traction

Evidence the founders have already done work to validate — bootstrapped tests, conviction, momentum that makes the company feel inevitable. They are seed investors spanning first dollar raised to the last dollar before Series A; raw metrics matter less than demonstrated commitment and learning.

“We see ourselves as seed phase investors, meaning you're somewhere between your first dollar raised and the last dollar raised that's going to get you to your Series A.” — Think Seed Like Homebrew (Mercury)
“What we really look for is if the founders have done enough work to convince themselves that this is what they want to spend the next decade of their career on.” — Hunter Walk
“The most exciting companies, from an investment perspective, feel like they are going to happen one way or another. Not that this company is only going to exist if Homebrew blesses it.” — Hunter Walk

Team

Strong founder-market fit and conviction — founders who have done enough work to commit a decade, who can recruit others to the cause. Solo founders are fundable but not ideal; an inability to attract a co-founder is a signal worth probing.

“What we really look for is if the founders have done enough work to convince themselves that this is what they want to spend the next decade of their career on.” — Think Seed Like Homebrew (Mercury)
“We invest in companies, but we're actually backing people.” — Homebrew Portfolio
“We invest in solo founders but think that being a solo founder is not ideal.” — Satya Patel
“If you're not able to convince one other person to join you in your cause, either you're not selling the story appropriately or maybe there's something wrong with the story.” — Satya Patel
“The most exciting companies, from an investment perspective, feel like they are going to happen one way or another. Not that this company is only going to exist if Homebrew blesses it.” — Hunter Walk

Business model

A tangible path to acquiring customers — not just the first ones but a cost-effective, repeatable acquisition channel. Addressability and go-to-market clarity outweigh abstract market math.

“How are you going to acquire your customers and what insights or unfair advantages do you have in doing so?” — Your Total Addressable Market Stat Is Probably a Lie
“Yes there are lots of retail stores which could benefit from your commerce and loyalty program solution but where do the first 1,000 customers come from?” — Hunter Walk
“When you're pitching investors focus on the A in TAM. It'll help make your strategy more tangible, expose the depth of thought you have” — Hunter Walk

Competition

Honest, reality-based competitive thinking. A self-serving 2x2 that always puts you in the upper-right is a red flag; they want a thoughtful, customer-grounded understanding of the landscape that would survive a competitor's critique.

“If you show me a competitive 2×2, I'm going to ask you what the competitors on the slide would say about it if they were critiquing the matrix categories and their placement.” — If Your Pitch Deck Has a Competitive 2×2, I'm Going to Ask You This Question
“I've never been presented one of these slides where the startup pitching isn't in the 'upper right' (canonical best) square.” — Hunter Walk
“When the discussion falls flat it's often because the slide isn't based in reality, the matrices are swerves made to enhance the startup's position but with very little actual connection to customer needs or strategic advantage.” — Hunter Walk
“This is one of those pitch deck slides that's similar to an iceberg — 90% of the the mass is below the surface.” — Hunter Walk

Why now

Timing tied to the market and the founder's insight — why this team, this market, right now. Founder-market fit and market timing are evaluated together; capital should help capture an insight whose moment has arrived.

“We're generally picking a team that has strong founder market fit. The market is really important in terms of timing.” — Think Seed Like Homebrew (Mercury)
“Capital then becomes something that's going to help you take advantage of an insight you have or a hypothesis you're working on.” — Hunter Walk
“is it the right time for a winner to emerge?” — Hunter Walk

The ask

A pitch that builds escalating belief — market, timing, team — before getting to terms. They lead/co-lead seed rounds; historically targeting 10-15% ownership, now writing mostly $100k-$500k checks from evergreen capital. They prioritize ownership over valuation on any single deal.

“Prioritize ownership over valuation on any given deal, but price drives your portfolio construction.” — Does valuation or ownership matter more to a seed VC? Yes.
“I call it The Belief Funnel. And your term sheet waits at the bottom.” — Hunter Walk
“Our strategy for Funds I, II, and III were basically to lead/co-lead seed rounds with a 10-15% ownership target.” — Hunter Walk
“Instead of an average check size approaching $2m, we'd scale back to mostly $100k-$500k (~20% of the time larger)” — Hunter Walk

What Homebrew rewards and penalizes

What excites Homebrew

  • Founder has firsthand experience with the pain and a clear, personal 'why' for spending a decade on it
  • The company feels inevitable — it's already happening through bootstrapped tests, not waiting for a VC's blessing
  • Strong founder-market fit paired with credible market timing
  • A go-to-market answer for where the first 1,000 customers come from and a repeatable acquisition channel
  • Honest, customer-grounded competitive thinking that would survive a competitor's critique

Watch-outs for Homebrew

  • An inflated TAM slide treated as a credential ('$80 GAZILLION DOLLARS of TAM')
  • A self-serving competitive 2x2 that always places the startup in the upper-right with no basis in reality
  • An exit slide in a seed deck
  • Solo founder who cannot convince a single co-founder to join — signals a story problem
  • A company that only exists if the investor blesses it

Who decides at Homebrew

Hunter Walk — Partner / Co-founder
“The most exciting companies, from an investment perspective, feel like they are going to happen one way or another. Not that this company is only going to exist if Homebrew blesses it.”
Satya Patel — Partner / Co-founder
“When we make an investment at the seed stage, we're trying to check the founding team, the market opportunity, and the product vision.”

What Homebrew actually backs

Where Homebrew is thinking now

Homebrew's published guidance

Benchmark your deck against Homebrew →

PitchLens grades your deck slide-by-slide against Homebrew's own published playbook, with a citation on every point.

← Browse all 124 VC firms · PitchLens home